News & insights
Black-American Trans Woman Activist of Jewish descent Acquitted of Racially Aggravated Harassment against white man
17.11.2026
A Black American Trans Woman Activist of Jewish descent has been acquitted of racially aggravated harassment following a prosecution arising from WhatsApp messages she sent to a white man calling out white supremacy, anti-Blackness, the genocide of the people in Gaza and the need for reparations for Afrikan peoples.
The Defendant was represented by Anthony Hudson KC (Matrix Chambers), leading Ife Thompson (Nexus Chambers Crime Team), instructed by Sinéad Vaughan and Adeela Khan of Commons Law.
PW, a Black American Trans Woman Activist of Jewish descent, faced a single charge of racially aggravated harassment, contrary to section 32(1)(a) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, at Southwark Crown Court, arising from WhatsApp messages she had sent.
The Crown subsequently offered no evidence against PW following service by the defence of a 24-page application to dismiss, a skeleton argument and two expert reports: an African American Vernacular English (AAVE) linguistic report and a report on anti-Blackness.
The case concerned allegations that PW’s messages to the complainant, a white man, in which she challenged white supremacy, expressed concerns about Israel’s actions in Gaza and addressed anti-Blackness, amounted to harassment of him on the basis of his race. The defence position was that these messages formed part of a discussion in which PW was exercising her right to raise concerns about human rights and racial injustice.
The Defence Arguments
The defence legal arguments raised several important issues:
- There was no evidence that PW had demonstrated hostility towards the complainant based on his membership, or presumed membership, of a racial group.
- Nothing in the content of the messages exchanged could properly be regarded as constituting harassment.
- The Crown had wrongly attributed Jewish descent to the complainant, when it was PW who had referred to her own Jewish descent in the WhatsApp exchange. The complainant had nowhere stated that he was Jewish.
- PW’s right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) was engaged.
Expert Evidence
The defence relied on two expert reports which provided important context to the WhatsApp exchange.
- Dr Andrews found that PW had herself been subjected to misogynoir and anti-Blackness during the WhatsApp conversation.
- Dr Davis found that PW’s linguistic practices were consistent with AAVE responses to experiencing anti-Black racism within a conversation with a white person.
The Prosecution Decision to Offer No Evidence
At a mention hearing, following service of the application to dismiss, the Crown Court Judge invited the Crown to further review the case. The Judge noted that, often when the term ‘racially aggravated’ is mentioned, the CPS can be inclined to pass the case on to the Judge to decide, rather than properly reviewing the evidence themselves and taking the necessary action where the offence charged is not in fact made out.
Following this further review, on 9 October 2026, the Crown wrote to the defence confirming:
“Following a full review of the case and consideration of the defendant’s application to dismiss, the prosecution confirms the full code test is no longer satisfied and that the prosecution now intends to offer no evidence in these proceedings.”
It is noteworthy that this was the second review undertaken by the Crown in this matter.
The prosecution’s decision to offer no evidence brought the proceedings to an end as the court entered a finding of Not Guilty, resulting in PW’s acquittal.
PW states – I never imagined this case happening in my life, it’s become clear after this case that slavery is over but the ideology is still prevalent. I am very concerned with how the police have handled this case. If we really want a better society, we all need to step out of our bubble and talk to someone from a different religion, sexual orientation, different culture, and community. We really need talk and listen to each other. We really need to get to know each other. We think we know each other but we don’t. By doing this we may discover we all have something in common.